Loading...

Positive Feedback Logo
Ad
Ad
Ad

Yes, Close To The Edge - Super Deluxe Edition

03-10-2025 | By Tom Gibbs | Issue 138

Rhino Entertainment continues to give the Yes catalog of albums the Super Deluxe Edition treatment with a new LP/CD/BD box set of the band's fifth studio album, 1972's Close To The Edge. A truly expansive multi-disc box set, Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition (SDE) offers not only new remasters of the album from both Bernie Grundman and Steven Wilson, but also includes a vast array of previously unreleased alternate tracks, single edits, instrumental tracks, and a live recording from the same year as the original album's release. Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition features the same package design as Rhino's previous entries in the series, with an LP-sized gatefold jacket that holds the 180 gram LP. There's also a full-sized, multi page booklet that features Roger Dean's artwork along with band photos from the recording sessions; music industry professional and journalist Syd Schwartz reprises his role once again to pen the booklet's informative new essay. 

The gatefold outer jacket contains die-cut slits on the left-side LP pocket that hold a Blu-ray and a compact disc, with each inserted in mini-LP jackets; the right side panel features four indented disc holders that house four additional compact discs. Close To The Edge is widely considered to be the number one prog rock album of all time, and was the first Yes album to feature artist Roger Dean's classic Yes logo design. A limited edition SDE box for Close To The Edge was also made available online with a signed Roger Dean lithograph; unfortunately for fans, at the time of this review, that set had completely sold out in the pre-order stage.

Yes, Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition, (1) 180 Gram LP, (5) Compact Discs, (1) BluRay Disc, $99.98

By the time Close To The Edge was released in September, 1972, the band's lineup had stabilized around keyboardist Rick Wakeman and guitarist Steve Howe, whose contributions were now fully integrated into the group's musical direction. When the band convened in London's Advision Studios in April that year, they set out to record their most ambitious album yet, Close To The Edge. Unlike their previous albums, Close To The Edge was built around three lengthy set pieces, the nearly twenty-minute long "Close To The Edge," along with a pair of tunes that clocked in at nearly ten minutes each, "And You And I," along with the song that would become the band's perennial concert opener, "Siberian Khatru." Although single edits of the lengthy title track were sent to radio stations, sales of Close To The Edge weren't propelled by the presence of a blockbuster single like "Roundabout" from their previous album, Fragile. Nonetheless, the album achieved impressive chart success in the UK and the US, reaching the No. 4 position on the Billboard album charts in the UK, as well as peaking at No. 3 on the US album charts. And Close To The Edge reached the platinum sales mark on both sides of the pond.

As previously mentioned, the 180 gram LP was remastered by Bernie Grundman, who also cut the lacquers at BG Mastering in Hollywood; the entire package was manufactured in Germany, where Optimal pressed the LP. Three of the five included CDs feature the 2025 original album mix remastered by Bernie Grundman; Steven Wilson's 2025 remix and instrumental tracks; and a generous selection of alternate takes, single edits, and rarities that are mostly previously unreleased. CDs four and five feature the full Yes concert from London's Rainbow Theatre that took place on December 16, 1972. By this point, the band had honed their live sound with new drummer Alan White, who'd come on board when original percussionist Bill Bruford left the band mid-tour. The Blu-ray disc features 24-bit/192kHz high-resolution digital files for Bernie Grundman's original album remaster; 24/96 high resolution files for Steven Wilson's album and instrumental remix; 24/48 files for Steven Wilson's 2025 Dolby Atmos mix; and 24/96 high-res files for Steven Wilson's 2025 5.1 DTS-HD MA mixes. Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition will thrill fans and completists alike, and is available for purchase online HERE; it can also be found at multiple online retailers as well as at your local independent record store. Here's a list of the contents of the individual discs:

Disc 1: Original Album Remastered

  1. Close To The Edge
  2. And You and I
  3. Siberian Khatru

Disc 2: Steven Wilson Remix and Instrumentals

  1. Close To The Edge
  2. And You and I
  3. Siberian Khatru
  4. Close To The Edge (Instrumental Remix)
  5. And You and I (Instrumental Remix)
  6. Siberian Khatru (Instrumental Remix)

Disc 3: Rarities

  1. America (Single Version)
  2. Total Mass Retain (Single Version)
  3. And You and I (Promo Radio Edit)
  4. Siberia (Studio Run-Through of "Siberian Khatru")
  5. Close To The Edge (Rough Mix)
  6. And You and I (Alternate Version)
  7. America ("Dry" Mix)
  8. Siberian Khatru (Steven Wilson Edit)
  9. Cord of Life (Steven Wilson Edit)
  10. Total Mass Retain (Steven Wilson Edit)

Disc 4: Live at The Rainbow, London, England, 12/16/72

  1. Siberian Khatru
  2. I've Seen All Good People
  3. Your Move
  4. All Good People
  5. Heart of the Sunrise 
  6. And You and I 
  7. Close To The Edge

Disc 5: Live at The Rainbow, London, England, 12/16/72

  1. Excerpts From "The Six Wives of Henry VIII" 
  2. Roundabout 
  3. Yours Is No Disgrace 
  4. Starship Trooper 
  5. Life Seeker
  6. Disillusion
  7. Würm

Blu-Ray (Original Recordings; Steven Wilson Remixes, Instrumentals, DTS HD MA 5.1, Dolby Atmos)

  1. Close To The Edge
  2. And You and I
  3. Siberian Khatru 

180 gram LP

Side One:

  1. Close To The Edge

Side Two:

  1. And You and I
  2. Siberian Khatru 

Listening Results

Clicking my name in the header above will reveal the full complement of components that occupy my dual audio setups. For Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition I used my all-analog system for the LP's evaluation. It features a pair of XSA Labs Vanguard compact monitor loudspeakers that offer an updated homage to classic British monitor designs like the LS3/5A. They run in tandem with a pair of Caldera 10 subwoofers that add a few extra octaves to the overall bass response. The system also features PS Audio's superb Stellar phono preamplifier, and the monitors are powered by my PrimaLuna EVO 300 tube integrated amplifier. Which now features RAY Tubes exclusively, with a matched quad of Reserve EL34 power tubes and three matched pairs of Select 12AU7 tubes in the input and driver sockets; the new tubes have elevated the amplifier's performance to an impressive new level of fidelity. My ProJect Classic turntable is mounted with an Ortofon Quintet Bronze moving coil cartridge that tracked Optimal's LP pressing perfectly. 

The 180 gram LP was razor-flat, with pristine, beautifully glossy, and defect-free surfaces that yielded no ticks or groove noise. The LP was encased in a rice paper-lined inner sleeve, which protected it from paper dust, scratching, and static buildup, and Bernie Grundman's new remaster of Close To The Edge was superb. Compared to my Atlantic label original, as well as several other reissue LPs I had on hand, the new SDE LP was among the best sounding of the bunch. Overly obsessive fans (myself included) have come to the realization that there's a fairly prominent edit following Steve Howe's acoustic guitar intro to "And You And I," right at the point where Chris Squire's bass guitar enters the proceedings. A number of remasters in the digital age have done a hatchet job on this transition, but Bernie gets it right on this remaster! Of course, Steven Wilson has gotten it right since he first tackled Close To The Edge about a decade ago, and his 2025 remix has even better clarity than his original attempt from 2016. 

As is my usual practice, I ripped the CDs and Blu-ray disc from Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition, converting them all to uncompressed .flac for my digital music server. The digital source system features a server/streaming rig from Euphony Audio in Croatia, and all digital files are converted by the system to DSD for playback through an SMSL VMV D2R DAC. Which streams into a new, French-designed Advance Paris Classic A12 integrated amplifier (review coming soon on Positive Feedback). It powerfully drives a pair of new production KLH Model Five loudspeakers that are thunderously supplemented by dual Caldera 12 subwoofers. The converted-to-DSD sound of the digital files was impressively good, especially Steven Wilson's 2025 stereo remixes. In fact, all of his remixes are even better than those from 2016; Wilson has definitely found a way to improve upon his usual level of perfection. The extensive collection of extras varies from very good to near studio quality, and even the live tracks from the Rainbow date are surprisingly superb, sounding better than most of the tracks from the live album Yessongs, which was sourced from this era of the band. Steven Wilson's new 5.1 DTS HD MA remixes are more discrete and more seamless than his work from 2016—he's obviously learned a few new remixing tricks since then! 

Final Thoughts

I first heard Close To The Edge in June, 1973, at a record store in Vallejo, California when I was fifteen years old; it's an encounter that's etched in my brain. I'd slipped away from my sister Maxine's house in the suburbs, and walked into downtown Vallejo, happening onto a secluded plaza where a loudspeaker placed outside the record store's entrance blasted music from Yes' just-released live album, Yessongs. I ventured inside, and they soon played Close To The Edge in its entirety; I basically stood catatonic for the album's runtime, and spent what little cash I had getting the LP. Then raced back to the house to play it on Maxine's console stereo; my journey into a lifelong love affair with prog rock had begun, and it started with Close To The Edge.

Admittedly, I was a tad underwhelmed by Bernie Grundman's remaster of Fragile: Super Deluxe Edition last year; I felt the sound quality was a bit lacking in ways that probably had to do with the source tapes. And I wasn't sure what to expect when I saw the press release for Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition—which offered zero information in terms of who was at the helm of the new remaster. Upon the set's arrival, one look inside confirmed that Bernie was again at the controls, and he pretty much nailed it with his 2025 remaster. And the icing on this already great set comes in the form of Steven Wilson's new remixes, which possess a greater degree of clarity and are more discrete than those from 2016, which I already considered to be masterworks. Many thanks to Taylor Perry of Shore Fire Media and Miranda Alston of Warner Music Group; Close To The Edge: Super Deluxe Edition comes very highly recommended!

Rhino Entertainment

rhino.com

All images courtesy of Rhino Entertainment, Shore Fire Media, and the author.