Positive Feedback Logo

Respighi Impressioni brasiliane, La Boutique fantasque

07-07-2016 | By John Marks | Issue 86

John Marks' first cross-published music review from The Tannhauser Gate (http://www.thetannhausergate.com) is of a composer near and dear to my heart for many years now:  Ottorino Respighi. I have many of his recordings various formats, including LP, CD, and SACD, but am always pleased to find a new recording that renews my delight with his creative greatness.

Thanks be then to John for bringing this blessing my way! Intrigued by John's rave about this recording to me, I listened to a rip of the SACD layer of this BIS disc. Yes, all those knowledgeable about provenance issues with BIS SACDs are aware that they are done from PCM masters...in this case, purportedly from an 88.2 kHz/24-bit master source. But I also know that there seems to be something ameliorative...an indefinable healing...that happens when PCM is sent on a march to DSD. 

Regardless of the provenance question, I must agree with John that this is a reference-quality recording of a great performance. I have listened to the entire recording several times over the past week, each time with increasing satisfaction. You pass it by to your own impoverishment, especially if you love Respighi!

Dr. David W. Robinson, E-in-C

Respighi Impressioni brasiliane, La Boutique fantasque
Liège Royal Philharmonic, John Neschling, conductor


I raved about this SACD/CD in my next-to-last column for Stereophile magazine. Having since then heard it played back on a variety of stereo systems, my continued exposure to it has only increased my respect.

I have not yet heard Andris Nelsons' and the Boston Symphony's Grammy-winning Shostakovich 10th symphony, which, perhaps, might be even better. But as of right now, the Liège Royal Philharmonic's Respighi Brazilian Impressions on BIS is the best new orchestral recording (not only in terms of recording quality, but also in performance) I have heard in years. Even if you rarely listen to classical music, this recording is well worth acquiring as material that shows off what a great stereo system can sound like.

Part of all that of course is owing to Ottorino Resphigi's near-cinematic skill as an orchestrator. (Indeed, there are those who scoff that Respighi was more of an orchestrator than a composer. And, truth be told, Respighi did tend to borrow from both historical and more recent sources for thematic material more often than would other composers, Ancient Airs and Dancesbeing one well-known example.) Resphigi wrote tone poems that were more like tone paintings. He had a unique gift to summon Impressionistic evocations of a "sense of place." His most famous works are the "Roman Triptych" of the orchestral sketches Pines of Rome, Fountains of Rome, and Roman Festivals, all of which have been longtime audiophile favorites.

Philharmonic Hall of Liège (1887).

Impressioni brasiliane's first movement, "Notte Tropicale," starts with celeste, divided first violins playing high on the E string, and harp. The violins' insistent rhythm and the beat accents from celeste and harp, in a space of no more than two measures, create both a sense of expectation, and the impression that the enveloping night is so quiet that you can hear a clock tick. Well, at least to me they do.

The movement continues with quiet flute flourishes leading to an oboe solo. String glissandi (slides) and piquant percussion such as tambourine and triangle add to the exotic ambiance, while at the same time giving any stereo system a fine old workout.

If CD or SACD is not your thing, eClassical has this recording available as 24/96 FLAC downloads, either the entire recording, or as individual movements. I think that spending no more than the princely sum of two dollars and 80 cents for a tremendous orchestral showpiece ("Notte Tropicale") is a bargain by any measure.

But if you only buy the first track, you would be denying yourself the pleasure of the other two movements of Impressioni brasiliane, as well as a knockout performance of Respighi's immensely popular ballet score The Enchanted Toy Shop.

The Enchanted Toy Shop is a series of dance movements (Tarantella, Mazurka, Cossack Dance, Cancan, Valse, and Galop) for boy and girl marionettes who come to life, and of course, they are in love with each other. Respighi borrowed catchy tunes from Rossini.

The entire eClassical download costs $16.52. Amazon has the SACD/CD on offer for $23.30. What's not to love? (Prices as of February 2016.)